Which Year To Avoid

NHTSA complaints and recalls, tallied plainly

Which model year should you avoid?

A lookup for car problems and recalls, built from NHTSA’s free public data. Each model page tallies complaints, crash and fire flags, reported injuries and deaths, and official recalls, then flags the weaker years with a method you can check.

Data fetched November 21, 2026, 7:02–7:16 p.m. America/Denver, for model years 2010–2024. Five models in this prototype.

Honda CR-V

Years to avoid: 2018, 2023, 2024

10,943 complaints · 95 recalls · model years 2010–2024

Open the year-by-year table

Toyota RAV4

Years to avoid: 2019, 2021, 2024

5,363 complaints · 78 recalls · model years 2010–2024

Open the year-by-year table

Ford F-150

Years to avoid: 2018, 2021, 2022

19,743 complaints · 183 recalls · model years 2010–2024

Open the year-by-year table

Chevrolet Equinox

Years to avoid: 2018

6,428 complaints · 41 recalls · model years 2010–2024

Open the year-by-year table

Nissan Rogue

Years to avoid: 2017, 2023

6,422 complaints · 71 recalls · model years 2010–2024

Open the year-by-year table

What the numbers are

Every count on this prototype was pulled from NHTSA’s complaints and recalls APIs. We query every official model-name variant (for example F-150 cab styles, CR-V Hybrid), then merge records by ODI number or recall campaign number so the same filing is not counted twice. We do not normalize by sales volume — we do not have a sourced sales figure — so popular trucks can look “worse” simply because more of them are on the road. We do divide the score by years on the market so a 2010 and a 2024 are not compared as raw totals alone.

A year is flagged Avoid when its age-adjusted score is at least 1.5 times that model’s median and it is one of the three highest years. Caution means above the median but not Avoid. The raw complaint column is always shown, so you can ignore the adjustment if you prefer. Details are on the methodology page.

Placeholders

Placeholder: display ad

Ad slot only. Nothing is loaded or sold here.

Placeholder: VIN history report (affiliate)

Reserved for a later vehicle-history / VIN report partner. No offer is live.

Placeholder: email signup

Free VIN recall-alert list — not wired up. No form is collected on this prototype.

Source

NHTSA Office of Defects Investigation, via nhtsa.gov/nhtsa-datasets-and-apis. Recall campaign links go to NHTSA’s public recall search. If you want to check a specific vehicle, use NHTSA’s own VIN or campaign lookup.